Best Homeowners Insurance Companies Of 2023

As a homeowner, your house and all the valuables inside add up to a big investment that deserves quality financial protection. Choosing the right homeowners insurance is vital to securing your most valuable asset.

Damaging storms, fires, and other disasters can mean months of costly rebuilding and replacement of belongings. Part of good preparation is buying coverage that will adequately protect your house and everything in it should the unexpected strike.

Home Insurance

How Many Homeowners Insurance Do You Need?

To determine how much homeowners insurance you need, consider the value of your home and belongings. The more your property is worth, the higher the coverage limits you'll want to consider.

  1. Home value. The amount of coverage for your home's structure should equal its replacement cost, which is the cost to rebuild your home. This is not the same as your home's market value, which factors in the value of the land. Replacement cost coverage ensures you have enough to rebuild your home in the event of a total loss.
  2. Personal belongings. Contents coverage protects your belongings, like furniture, clothing, and electronics. Choose a coverage amount that would allow you to replace most of your belongings in case of loss. Create an inventory of your home to determine appropriate coverage limits.
  3. Additional coverage. Consider adding coverage for other structures like garages, pools, or fences. You may also want coverage for valuables like jewelry, art, collectibles, or sports equipment which typically have lower coverage limits under a standard policy.
  4. Liability coverage. Liability insurance protects you in case someone is injured at your home or by your property. Higher coverage limits, such as $500,000 or $1 million, provide more protection for potentially expensive medical bills and legal claims.
  5. Deductible. A higher deductible, such as $2,500 or $5,000 versus $500 or $1,000, will lower your premium but means you pay more out of pocket for claims before coverage kicks in. Choose a deductible amount you can afford in case of a claim.

Reviewing your coverage needs annually and making adjustments as needed will ensure your homeowner's insurance policy adequately protects your property and financial well-being. With the right amount of coverage, you can rest easy knowing your home and belongings are properly insured.

What Does Homeowners Insurance Cover?

As a homeowner, it is important to understand exactly what your homeowner's insurance policy covers in the event of damage or loss. Most standard policies protect you financially in a few key areas:

  • Dwelling coverage: This covers the physical structure of your home, including fixtures like plumbing and wiring, if it is damaged or destroyed by an insured event like fire, theft, or weather events. The amount of coverage you buy depends on the rebuilding cost of your home.
  • Other structures: This provides coverage for detached structures on your property like garages, sheds, and fences. Coverage amounts typically depend on the replacement cost of the structures.
  • Personal property: This covers the contents of your home like furniture, electronics, clothing, and other belongings. You determine and select the coverage amount for your personal property.
  • Loss of use: This coverage pays for additional living expenses if you cannot live in your home due to an insured event. It covers costs like temporary housing, food, and transportation.
  • Personal liability: This protects you financially if someone is injured at your home and decides to pursue legal action against you. It covers costs like medical bills, legal fees, and settlements.

To ensure you have adequate coverage, you must regularly re-evaluate the replacement cost of your home and belongings and adjust coverage amounts accordingly. You should also consider additional coverage like flood insurance if you live in a high-risk area. Comparing quotes from multiple insurers can help you find the best value. With the right homeowner's insurance coverage, you can feel confident your most valuable assets are protected.

How We Chose the Best Homeowners Insurance Companies

To determine the best homeowners insurance companies, we evaluated the top national providers based on several factors important to homeowners.

Financial stability

We considered the financial stability and claims-paying ability of each insurer. Companies with an “A” rating or better from A.M. Best, indicating superior financial strength, received higher scores.

Coverage options

The range of coverage options, including additional riders for valuables like jewelry or art, was also assessed. Companies that offer comprehensive coverage for disasters common to the region, e.g. flood or earthquake insurance, ranked higher.


We compared quotes from each company for a sample home in multiple locations across the U.S. to determine which insurers typically offer lower premiums. However, cheaper rates alone do not make a company the “best” if its coverage or service is lacking.

Customer satisfaction

Customer reviews and ratings on sites like JD Power, Consumer Reports, and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners were analyzed to identify companies with a history of keeping customers satisfied. Superior service, quick claims handling, and competitive rates are most valued by homeowners.


Companies that offer a variety of discounts, especially those for new homes, home security systems, bundling with auto policies, and good credit, received higher scores. Such discounts can help lower premiums over time.

To summarize, the insurance providers that ranked the highest in our review demonstrated financial stability, offered comprehensive coverage with additional riders, provided competitive rates, had a record of outstanding customer service, and offered discounts that could yield long-term savings. By choosing a company based on these factors, homeowners can gain peace of mind knowing their largest asset is well-protected in the event of unforeseen circumstances.

Which Are The Best International Health Insurance Providers

Amica: Best Overall Homeowners Insurance Company

Superior Financial Stability

Amica Mutual Insurance Company has been in business since 1907, demonstrating superior financial stability and security. According to A.M. Best, Amica has an A+ rating, indicating a superior ability to meet ongoing insurance obligations. This means that even after a catastrophic event, Amica has the financial strength to pay out claims to all policyholders.

Comprehensive Coverage Options

Amica offers a range of coverage options to suit your specific needs, including:

  • Basic coverage: Provides protection for your home's structure and personal belongings in the event of disasters like fire, theft, or vandalism.
  • Additional living expenses: Covers temporary housing costs if you can't live in your home due to a covered loss.
  • Personal liability: Protects you in the event someone is injured at your home and decides to pursue legal action.
  • Flooding and earthquakes: Available as optional add-ons for homes in high-risk areas.

Valuable Discounts

As an Amica customer, you have access to a range of discounts that can help lower your premiums, including:

  1. Multi-policy: Receive a discount for bundling your home and auto policies.
  2. Security systems: Get a discount for installing an approved burglar or fire alarm system.
  3. New homebuyer: New homeowners can receive a discount for their first 3 years.
  4. Loyalty: Earn a discount for every year you remain a customer.

Superior Customer Satisfaction

Amica is renowned for providing an exceptional customer experience. According to J.D. Power's 2020 U.S. Home Insurance Study, Amica received the highest score among homeowners insurance companies in the J.D. Power Customer Satisfaction Index. Amica's customers report an easy claims process, helpful and friendly service, and fast payouts. For homeowners seeking the best overall value and experience, Amica is an excellent choice.

USAA: Best for Military Families

Coverage and Discounts

As a military family, USAA provides coverage tailored to your unique needs. They offer standard homeowners insurance to protect your dwelling, personal property, and liability, as well as additional coverage for high-value items, identity theft, and natural disasters. USAA also provides coverage for temporary housing if you are deployed or relocated.

USAA offers substantial discounts for military members, including a discount of up to 15% for bundling multiple policies. They also provide discounts for new homes, homes with safety features like fire alarms and sprinkler systems, and for members with a good claims history. Additional discounts are available for members who have been with USAA for multiple years.

Customer Service

USAA is renowned for providing superior customer service. They make it easy to start a claim 24 hours a day via phone, mobile app, or online. Claims adjusters are available for help throughout the entire claims process. USAA has a long-standing reputation for fast, fair claims handling and payment. They aim to settle claims quickly and efficiently.

Availability and Eligibility

USAA insurance is only available to military members, veterans, and their families. You must be an enlisted member (current or former) of the U.S. military, a commissioned officer, or the spouse or child of someone who meets these criteria to be eligible for USAA insurance coverage. USAA currently serves over 13 million members.

In summary, USAA should be at the top of your list if you want specialized coverage and discounts tailored to military families and exceptional customer service. For those who are eligible, USAA is hard to beat for homeowners insurance. If you do not meet their eligibility criteria, you will need to consider other top-rated insurers.

Erie Insurance: Best for Customer Satisfaction

Superior Customer Satisfaction

Erie Insurance receives extremely high customer satisfaction ratings year after year. In J.D. Power's 2020 U.S. Home Insurance Study, Erie ranked highest in customer satisfaction among homeowners insurance companies in the North Central region for the 11th consecutive year. Erie also ranked highest in the nation in customer satisfaction according to the study.

Personalized Service

Erie Insurance provides personalized service through its network of independent agents. Agents get to know customers and their unique needs to determine appropriate coverage and help file claims. Erie's commitment to service and relationships with longtime customers contributes to its strong customer loyalty and retention rates.

Competitive Rates

While Erie Insurance receives top marks for service, it also offers competitive rates for homeowners insurance. Rates vary significantly based on factors like location, coverage amounts, and claims history, so the only way to find out how much Erie would charge you is to get a quote. Erie frequently runs discounts and promotions like bundling auto and home insurance or installing safety features in the home.

Optional Coverages

In addition to standard homeowners insurance, Erie offers coverage for valuables like jewelry, art, and collectibles. Erie also provides coverage for additional living expenses if you can't live in your home due to a covered loss. Other options include coverage for identity theft, water backup, and service line coverage. Erie aims to provide comprehensive protection for homeowners.

To summarize, Erie Insurance should be at the top of your list if you value superior customer service, personalized attention, and competitive rates. While Erie primarily operates in the Mid-Atlantic and Midwestern U.S. and 12 states, their award-winning service and coverage options make them worth considering if they operate in your area. For the best experience, connect with an Erie Insurance agent to discuss your homeowner's insurance needs.

American Family: Best for Discounts and Bundling

Competitive Rates and Discounts

American Family offers competitive rates for homeowners insurance, with additional discounts available to help lower your premium. As an American Family customer, you can save by bundling multiple policies together, such as home and auto insurance. You may also qualify for discounts for installing safety features in your home like smoke detectors, a security system, or storm shutters. American Family rewards long-term customers with discounts for continuous coverage.

Broad Coverage Options

American Family provides comprehensive coverage for your home and belongings. Their standard homeowner's insurance policy covers damage from events like fire, theft, vandalism, and weather events. You can also add coverage for valuables like jewelry, art, and collectibles. Additional coverage options include:

  1. Flood insurance: Protects against damage from surface water flooding.
  2. Earthquake insurance: Covers damage resulting from earthquakes and tremors.
  3. Identity theft protection: Helps monitor and resolve cases of identity theft.

Highly Rated

American Family receives very good reviews and ratings from industry experts and customers. They have an A rating for financial stability from AM Best, indicating they have an excellent ability to pay out claims. American Family is also accredited by the Better Business Bureau, where they maintain an A+ rating. Most customer reviews praise American Family for their customer service, affordable rates, and fast claims processing.

Easy Claims Process

If you experience damage to your home, American Family aims to make the claims process as straightforward as possible. You can start a claim on their website or mobile app and connect with an agent to guide you through the necessary steps. American Family uses local adjusters to evaluate the damage, so you can expect an adjuster to inspect your home quickly after starting a claim. They offer additional services like helping find temporary housing or storage for belongings during repairs. Overall, American Family works to settle claims fairly and promptly.

State Farm: Largest Homeowners Insurer in the U.S.

Largest Homeowners Insurer in the U.S.

As the largest homeowners insurance provider in the United States, State Farm insures more than 65 million policies nationwide. Due to its size and financial stability, State Farm offers competitive rates and a variety of coverage options for homeowners.

  1. Coverage Options: State Farm provides standard coverage like dwelling, personal property, and liability insurance. They also offer additional coverage options such as replacement cost coverage, coverage for valuables like jewelry or art, and coverage for natural disasters.
  2. Discounts: State Farm offers many discounts to help lower premiums, including discounts for bundling multiple policies, installing safety features like fire alarms or sprinkler systems, and being claim-free. They also offer discounts for new homeowners, students, and seniors.
  3. Claims Process: State Farm has a straightforward claims process. You can start a claim on their website or mobile app and an agent will contact you to get details about your claim. State Farm aims to settle claims quickly and has a large network of contractors and repair professionals to help with the claims process.
  4. Availability: State Farm operates in all 50 states, so their homeowner's insurance policies are widely available across the country. They have nearly 19,000 agents in the U.S. and Canada to help you find a policy.
  5. Financial Stability: As an established company, State Farm is financially stable. They have an A++ rating from A.M. Best, indicating superior financial strength to pay out claims. State Farm has been in business since 1922, so they have a long, proven history.

Overall, State Farm is a reputable provider of homeowners insurance with competitive rates, extensive coverage, and financial stability. For many homeowners, State Farm can provide peace of mind that you have quality coverage and support in the event of a claim. With their availability across all states, State Farm is worth considering for your homeowner's insurance needs.

Homeowners Insurance FAQs: Get Answers to Your Questions

What does homeowners insurance cover?

Homeowners insurance provides coverage for damage to your home and belongings due to events like fire, theft, vandalism, and natural disasters. Standard policies cover:

  • Your home's structure including fixtures like plumbing and wiring
  • Personal belongings like furniture, electronics, clothing, and other household items
  • Additional living expenses if you can't live in your home due to damage
  • Liability coverage for injuries that happen at your home

How much coverage do I need?

The amount of coverage you need depends on the value of your home and belongings. Make sure you have enough to completely rebuild your home and replace all contents. You can determine estimates using online calculators or by getting appraisals. It's best to reevaluate your coverage every few years in case values have increased.

What factors determine my premium?

Several factors are used to calculate your homeowners' insurance premium:

  1. The value and location of your home - More expensive homes in areas prone to natural disasters or crime typically have higher premiums.
  2. The amount of coverage you choose - Higher coverage limits mean higher premiums.
  3. The type of home you have - Premiums are usually higher for log homes, historic homes, or mobile homes.
  4. Your deductible amount - A higher deductible (the amount you pay out of pocket for claims) means a lower premium.
  5. Your claims history - Frequent claims or large past claims can increase your premium.
  6. Additional discounts - You may qualify for discounts like bundling with other policies, installing protective devices like alarms or sprinklers, or being claims-free for a certain period.

Do I need additional coverage?

Consider adding coverage like flood insurance if you live in a high-risk area, earthquake insurance in seismically active regions, or umbrella insurance for higher liability limits. You can also add riders to cover valuables like jewelry, art, electronics, or recreational equipment. Review all options with your insurance agent to determine what additional coverage is right for your needs.


In conclusion, protecting your home and everything in it should be a top priority. Reviewing your coverage needs and shopping around for the best homeowners insurance for your situation can provide peace of mind that you've done what you can safeguard your investment.

The companies profiled here offer competitive rates, strong financial stability, and a range of policy options to suit most homeowners. While no one can predict what the future may hold, you can at least prepare for the unexpected by choosing a reputable insurer and the right level of coverage for your home. The time you invest now in finding the best homeowners insurance for you can pay off substantially down the road.

No comments
Post a Comment

Post a Comment